Best Cocktail 2026

Seahorse

|

Brown Butter Margarita

Seahorse

Toronto, ON

By Lindsay Brennan | Photography by Johnny C.Y. Lam

At Toronto’s Seahorse, a bustling raw bar with low, dark lighting and tables filled with oysters and seafood, a beautifully balanced margarita gets an unexpected upgrade with the addition of brown butter.

Most would agree that almost anything is exponentially better with brown butter, but finding it in a margarita is particularly intriguing. Rich, nutty and subtly savoury, it gives the cocktail a distinctly gastronomic quality while preserving everything bright, salty and refreshing about a great margarita.

And it is incredibly good.

The richness of the brown butter against fresh lime, salt and tequila makes the drink rounder and more generous, without weighing it down. What sounds unexpected on paper tastes completely natural in the glass. So much so that brown butter in a margarita suddenly seems like an obvious idea.

It’s inventive without trying too hard to be clever. Familiar enough to give you everything you want from a classic margarita, but with a savoury richness that makes it completely memorable.

As Canada’s cocktail game reaches new heights, the Brown Butter Margarita at Seahorse stands out for being playful, thoughtful and, most importantly, absolutely delicious.