
Editorial by Lindsay Brennan | Photography by Johnny C.Y. Lam
Restaurant
Les Incompetents
City
St. Catharines, ON
Address
386 St. Paul St
Learn More & Book
Reserve for Tonight
There’s something irreverent about a restaurant called Les Incompetents. The name, borrowed from Home Alone, suggests a willingness not to take things too seriously. At this self-described “French(ish)” bar in downtown St. Catharines, there’s plenty of playfulness to go around. But beneath the humour and swagger is cooking of remarkable confidence, with seafood taking centre stage.

Chef Zach Smith, already well known in Niagara for his celebrated Fat Rabbit, has turned his attention from land to sea. For the B.C.-raised chef, it’s something of a homecoming, with his earliest food memories closely tied to the Pacific coast. Growing up, he pulled crabs from the ocean with his father, while whole salmon, spot prawns and Dungeness crab marked family celebrations. Those experiences stayed with him through a career that took him from Vancouver to Bar Raval in Toronto and eventually Niagara. At Les Incompetents, they find a new expression, combining a personal connection to seafood with the pleasures of a French-inspired neighbourhood bar.

Downtown St. Catharines has an unsettled, sometimes hard-edged character. The contrast of Les Incompetents is striking. Inside, the mood shifts. The room is lively and welcoming, with much of the action centred on the kitchen bar, where watching the cooks at work is part of the appeal.
Take a seat at the counter and the seafood immediately catches your attention. Gleaming fish and shellfish rest on ice, while the kitchen brigade works just beyond. The raw bar is a celebration of the sea, with an impressive display. Argentine shrimp, Peruvian scallop crudo, Nordic shrimp salad, mussels en escabèche and freshly shucked oysters. The selection is ambitious, but the preparations remain refreshingly direct, allowing the quality of the seafood to take the lead.


The menu has a distinctly southern French accent, though it’s interpreted with a freedom that makes the “French(ish)” description feel deliberate. The jambon-beurre, generously layered with Saint Brigid’s butter and herbes de Provence, is served with craquelins and cornichons. Rich butter and savoury ham meet the crunch of craquelins and the sharpness of cornichons. A puttanesca tartine layers anchovies, caramelized onions and tuna into a deeply savoury bite. Both dishes take familiar French and Mediterranean flavours in playful, satisfying directions.


Then there’s the tomato salad, a convincing argument for the pleasures of summer produce. Ripe tomatoes meet a rich tonnato sauce and smoked sardines, finished with crunchy breadcrumbs. The sweetness and acidity of the tomatoes cut through the richness of the sauce, while sardines lend smoky depth and breadcrumbs add texture.
What connects Les Incompetents to Fat Rabbit is Smith’s command of seasoning and texture. His instinct for knowing just how far to push a flavour, when to introduce acidity and how a little crunch can transform a dish. Nothing is tentative, yet the individual ingredients remain distinct. At Fat Rabbit, his instincts are applied to meat; at Les Incompetents, they translate to seafood and the brighter, more bracing flavours of the Mediterranean.

French and Canadian wines, local beers and whimsical cocktails are well-matched to the kitchen’s playful spirit. Whether you’re seated at the counter watching the cooks work or settled in with friends around a table, the pleasure is in the informality: good food, lively company and the freedom to make an evening of it.
Amid the rougher edges of downtown St. Catharines, Les Incompetents offers a striking contrast. Inside, pristine seafood, bold Mediterranean flavours and a playful spirit set the tone for a restaurant that’s as inviting as it is accomplished. There’s an irreverence to the experience, from the name to the menu, but behind it all is the unmistakable skill and precision of chef Zach Smith. The restaurant may not take itself too seriously, but the cooking gives you every reason to.
The Top 10
2026 Winners
-
Restaurant Capelin
Tasting MenuSt. Catharines, ON -
Sushi Jun
OmakaseCalgary, AB -
Snack Haüs
TavernWinnipeg, MB -
3 Pierres 1 Feu
Afro-CaribbeanMontréal, QC -
Angela Pastificio
ItalianVancouver, BC -
Coquette
BistroSaint-Anne-de-Beaupré, QC -
Touk
CambodianVancouver, BC -
LORE
Tasting MenuCollingwood, ON -
Les Incompetents
BistroSt. Catharines, ON -
Bar Eugenie
BistroToronto, ON










