
Editorial by Lindsay Brennan | Photography by Johnny C.Y. Lam
Restaurant
Restaurant Capelin
City
St. Catharines, ON
Address
31 James St
Learn More & Book
Reserve for Tonight
Summer light pours through the large windows at Capelin, illuminating white subway tiles, cobalt-blue details, touches of gold and fresh wood. Everything in the bright, 12-seat restaurant feels carefully considered, but nothing is overly designed. It’s more like being invited into someone’s exceptionally cool kitchen than entering a restaurant. Alex Seaborn is cooking just a few feet away, while his wife and business partner, Kat, pours wine, introduces ingredients and chats with guests. There’s little separation between kitchen, service and diner, and before long, the evening begins to feel more like an extraordinary dinner party than a restaurant.

Outside, downtown St. Catharines carries on with its gritty, sometimes chaotic energy. Yet for anyone following Niagara’s evolving culinary scene, the calibre of cooking here should come as little surprise. The region’s extraordinary abundance of vegetables, herbs, freshwater fish and meat is matched by some of Canada’s most interesting wine, cider and spirits producers. Its proximity to Toronto brings talent, vision and an audience willing to make the trip, while still leaving enough distance for Niagara to develop a culinary identity of its own. Capelin seems to gather much of that energy into one very small room.

Kat and Alex came to Niagara from the East Coast with experience in the Prince Edward Island and Toronto dining scenes and a particular love for fresh fish and seafood. Their approach is intensely personal, built around the pleasure of cooking for people and sharing the remarkable ingredients available to them. With just over a dozen seats, there’s nowhere for the smallest details to go unnoticed. From the rhythm of the service to the progression of the menu, everything has been carefully thought through, yet the atmosphere remains relaxed.

That same care extends to the ingredients. A close relationship with Affinity Fish and other like-minded purveyors has allowed Capelin to source exceptional, sustainably caught freshwater fish from Lake Ontario. Herbs and vegetables come from the garden at nearby Restaurant Pearl Morissette, while wines, ciders and spirits from small-scale producers across Niagara find their way into the glasses. None of it feels like a checklist of provenance, but rather an expression of what surrounds them. The relationships matter as much as the ingredients, something that becomes clear whenever Kat introduces the people behind what’s on the plate.
Alex’s cooking is distinctly Canadian, drawing freely on different techniques while remaining firmly rooted in the ingredients and seasons. There is real depth to the flavours, but also a lightness that makes the pacing of the menu particularly compelling. Richness is tempered by acidity, delicate textures punctuated by crunch. Each course builds on the last, with a restraint that allows the ingredients to remain the focus.


A delicate dashi custard arrives early in the meal and sets the tone for what follows. Inspired by Japanese chawanmushi, it’s made with local eggs and dashi infused with dried seaweed from New Brunswick, giving the impossibly silky custard a deep, savoury foundation. House-made soy sauce brings another layer of umami, while locally grown hazelnuts add richness and crunch. Fresh purple peas from Grumpy’s Greens, an urban farm in nearby St. Catharines, bring a delicate sweetness and gentle bite that balance the richness beautifully. What appears deceptively simple reveals layer after layer of flavour and texture. And the hazelnuts alone are enough to make a convert out of anyone who has never quite understood their appeal.


The fish is every bit as compelling. Albacore, lake trout and whitefish reveal just how exciting these ingredients can be when treated with this much care. At a time when imported seafood so often dominates the conversation around fine dining, Capelin makes a persuasive case for looking closer to home. Lake Ontario’s freshwater fish take their rightful place alongside more familiar delicacies, handled with the same precision and respect. There’s no grand statement being made, just a chef making the most of ingredients he knows and believes in.


Then there’s the focaccia. Perfectly made and dangerously easy to devour, it presents something of a dilemma. Eat it all immediately, or exercise enough restraint to save a little for the courses that follow? Those who manage the latter are rewarded with the pleasure of soaking up every last drop of flavour left on the plate.
The drinks are just as thoughtfully considered. Niagara’s remarkable diversity finds its way into the glass through producers such as Therianthropy, whose wines offer another expression of the region. Revel Cider’s The Space Between Words becomes a vermouth soda, refreshing and inventive without feeling unnecessarily elaborate. Local wines, ciders and spirits sit comfortably alongside bottles from farther afield, chosen with the same curiosity and attention to detail as the ingredients in the kitchen.

Even dessert feels like a natural continuation of the meal. A crème fraîche ice cream brings the same attention to texture and balance that defines the savoury courses, its gentle acidity providing a welcome counterpoint to the richness. And for those inclined to linger, Capelin’s impressive digestif selection is another pleasure altogether. Local and Italian amari offer plenty of reasons to stay for one more glass, and choosing just one is no easy task.
What distinguishes Capelin is the intimacy of the experience. Kat and Alex have created something that feels less like a traditional tasting-menu restaurant and more like an invitation into their world. Their enthusiasm for the ingredients, the producers and the people gathered around the counter is infectious, and the care behind every detail is unmistakable.

Capelin is reason enough to make the trip to St. Catharines, and a compelling introduction to what’s happening in the Niagara region. The growing community of chefs, farmers, fishers, winemakers and beverage producers is shaping a culinary identity that feels increasingly confident and distinctly Canadian. Capelin captures that energy, but its greatest achievement is making something so ambitious feel so personal.
By the time the evening draws to a close, the summer light has faded, the last glasses are being poured and conversation is still moving around the counter. Outside, downtown St. Catharines carries on as before. Inside, it’s hard to believe that so much extraordinary cooking, beautiful wine and genuine warmth can come together in such a small space. As Air Canada’s Best New Restaurant of 2026, Capelin offers a compelling glimpse of what the future of Canadian dining might look like. And it’s well worth making the trip.
The Top 10
2026 Winners
-
Restaurant Capelin
Tasting MenuSt. Catharines, ON -
Sushi Jun
OmakaseCalgary, AB -
Snack Haüs
TavernWinnipeg, MB -
3 Pierres 1 Feu
Afro-CaribbeanMontréal, QC -
Angela Pastificio
ItalianVancouver, BC -
Coquette
BistroSaint-Anne-de-Beaupré, QC -
Touk
CambodianVancouver, BC -
LORE
Tasting MenuCollingwood, ON -
Les Incompetents
BistroSt. Catharines, ON -
Bar Eugenie
BistroToronto, ON










